config-list.mk Darwin: Use --with-gnu-as
Checks
Commit Message
Hi!
config-list.mk Darwin: Use --with-gnu-as for mass-building tests
As `config-list.mk` is probably mostly used on Linux system, where
Apple's tools aren't around. Let's use --with-gnu-as instead to have
an useable assembler.
contrib/ChangeLog:
* config-list.mk (i686-apple-darwin): Use --with-gnu-as.
(i686-apple-darwin9): Ditto.
(i686-apple-darwin10): Ditto.
(powerpc-darwin8): Ditto.
(powerpc-darwin7): Ditto.
(powerpc64-darwin): Ditto.
(x86_64-apple-darwin): Ditto.
Okay for trunk?
Thanks,
Jan-Benedict
--
Comments
Hi Jan-Benedict,
> config-list.mk Darwin: Use --with-gnu-as for mass-building tests
>
> As `config-list.mk` is probably mostly used on Linux system, where
> Apple's tools aren't around. Let's use --with-gnu-as instead to have
> an useable assembler.
>
> contrib/ChangeLog:
>
> * config-list.mk (i686-apple-darwin): Use --with-gnu-as.
> (i686-apple-darwin9): Ditto.
> (i686-apple-darwin10): Ditto.
> (powerpc-darwin8): Ditto.
> (powerpc-darwin7): Ditto.
> (powerpc64-darwin): Ditto.
> (x86_64-apple-darwin): Ditto.
this doesn't seem right: binutils toplevel configure.ac has gas in
noconfigdirs for all but i?86-*-darwin*.
Rainer
Hi Jan-Benedict,
> On 15 Aug 2023, at 20:36, Jan-Benedict Glaw <jbglaw@lug-owl.de> wrote:
> config-list.mk Darwin: Use --with-gnu-as for mass-building tests
>
> As `config-list.mk` is probably mostly used on Linux system, where
> Apple's tools aren't around. Let's use --with-gnu-as instead to have
> an useable assembler.
* Actually I’m somewhat surprised that an “out of the tin” binutils assembler
would work for any arch other than probably x86_64 (which is what Adacore
folks supported for a while). Otherwise, I’d kind of expect that the mach-o-specific
asm directives would trip things up quite quickly. GAS is not going to produce
any sensible relocations for powerpc (I have a BFD patch, but it needs some
polish)
* Does this prevent it working properly, in the event that a Linux user has
an installation of mach-o tools (e.g. cctools or llvm)?
(there are several Linux-buildable branches floating around - and I am
working on making something more ‘official’)
* Other than those questions, no objection from me (i.e. OK for trunk).
Iain
>
> contrib/ChangeLog:
>
> * config-list.mk (i686-apple-darwin): Use --with-gnu-as.
> (i686-apple-darwin9): Ditto.
> (i686-apple-darwin10): Ditto.
> (powerpc-darwin8): Ditto.
> (powerpc-darwin7): Ditto.
> (powerpc64-darwin): Ditto.
> (x86_64-apple-darwin): Ditto.
>
> diff --git a/contrib/config-list.mk b/contrib/config-list.mk
> index e570b13c71b..02d1a4fe6d2 100644
> --- a/contrib/config-list.mk
> +++ b/contrib/config-list.mk
> @@ -47,7 +47,9 @@ LIST = aarch64-elf aarch64-freebsd13 aarch64-linux-gnu aarch64-rtems \
> hppa-linux-gnuOPT-enable-sjlj-exceptions=yes hppa64-linux-gnu \
> hppa64-hpux11.3 \
> hppa64-hpux11.0OPT-enable-sjlj-exceptions=yes \
> - i686-pc-linux-gnu i686-apple-darwin i686-apple-darwin9 i686-apple-darwin10 \
> + i686-pc-linux-gnu \
> + i686-apple-darwinOPT-with-gnu-as i686-apple-darwin9OPT-with-gnu-as \
> + i686-apple-darwin10OPT-with-gnu-as \
> i686-freebsd13 i686-kfreebsd-gnu \
> i686-netbsdelf9 \
> i686-openbsd i686-elf i686-kopensolaris-gnu i686-gnu \
> @@ -75,8 +77,8 @@ LIST = aarch64-elf aarch64-freebsd13 aarch64-linux-gnu aarch64-rtems \
> nvptx-none \
> or1k-elf or1k-linux-uclibc or1k-linux-musl or1k-rtems \
> pdp11-aout \
> - powerpc-darwin8 \
> - powerpc-darwin7 powerpc64-darwin powerpc-freebsd13 powerpc-netbsd \
> + powerpc-darwin8OPT-with-gnu-as \
> + powerpc-darwin7OPT-with-gnu-as powerpc64-darwinOPT-with-gnu-as powerpc-freebsd13 powerpc-netbsd \
> powerpc-eabisimaltivec powerpc-eabisim ppc-elf \
> powerpc-eabialtivec powerpc-xilinx-eabi powerpc-eabi \
> powerpc-rtems \
> @@ -96,7 +98,7 @@ LIST = aarch64-elf aarch64-freebsd13 aarch64-linux-gnu aarch64-rtems \
> sparc-wrs-vxworks sparc64-elf sparc64-rtems sparc64-linux \
> sparc64-netbsd sparc64-openbsd \
> v850e1-elf v850e-elf v850-elf v850-rtems vax-linux-gnu \
> - vax-netbsdelf visium-elf x86_64-apple-darwin x86_64-gnu \
> + vax-netbsdelf visium-elf x86_64-apple-darwinOPT-with-gnu-as x86_64-gnu \
> x86_64-pc-linux-gnuOPT-with-fpmath=avx \
> x86_64-elfOPT-with-fpmath=sse x86_64-freebsd13 x86_64-netbsd \
> x86_64-w64-mingw32 \
>
>
> Okay for trunk?
>
> Thanks,
> Jan-Benedict
>
>
> --
Hi Rainer!
On Tue, 2023-08-15 21:49:37 +0200, Rainer Orth <ro@CeBiTec.Uni-Bielefeld.DE> wrote:
> > config-list.mk Darwin: Use --with-gnu-as for mass-building tests
> >
> > As `config-list.mk` is probably mostly used on Linux system, where
> > Apple's tools aren't around. Let's use --with-gnu-as instead to have
> > an useable assembler.
> >
> > contrib/ChangeLog:
> >
> > * config-list.mk (i686-apple-darwin): Use --with-gnu-as.
> > (i686-apple-darwin9): Ditto.
> > (i686-apple-darwin10): Ditto.
> > (powerpc-darwin8): Ditto.
> > (powerpc-darwin7): Ditto.
> > (powerpc64-darwin): Ditto.
> > (x86_64-apple-darwin): Ditto.
>
> this doesn't seem right: binutils toplevel configure.ac has gas in
> noconfigdirs for all but i?86-*-darwin*.
You are right, I have to retract this patch. I had a similar patch
running for some Solaris variant and initially built this one
accordingly. However, in the end it didn't work (as you expected from
configure.ac), but I didn't drop it from my patch directory.
Sorry for the noise,
Jan-Benedict
--
@@ -47,7 +47,9 @@ LIST = aarch64-elf aarch64-freebsd13 aarch64-linux-gnu aarch64-rtems \
hppa-linux-gnuOPT-enable-sjlj-exceptions=yes hppa64-linux-gnu \
hppa64-hpux11.3 \
hppa64-hpux11.0OPT-enable-sjlj-exceptions=yes \
- i686-pc-linux-gnu i686-apple-darwin i686-apple-darwin9 i686-apple-darwin10 \
+ i686-pc-linux-gnu \
+ i686-apple-darwinOPT-with-gnu-as i686-apple-darwin9OPT-with-gnu-as \
+ i686-apple-darwin10OPT-with-gnu-as \
i686-freebsd13 i686-kfreebsd-gnu \
i686-netbsdelf9 \
i686-openbsd i686-elf i686-kopensolaris-gnu i686-gnu \
@@ -75,8 +77,8 @@ LIST = aarch64-elf aarch64-freebsd13 aarch64-linux-gnu aarch64-rtems \
nvptx-none \
or1k-elf or1k-linux-uclibc or1k-linux-musl or1k-rtems \
pdp11-aout \
- powerpc-darwin8 \
- powerpc-darwin7 powerpc64-darwin powerpc-freebsd13 powerpc-netbsd \
+ powerpc-darwin8OPT-with-gnu-as \
+ powerpc-darwin7OPT-with-gnu-as powerpc64-darwinOPT-with-gnu-as powerpc-freebsd13 powerpc-netbsd \
powerpc-eabisimaltivec powerpc-eabisim ppc-elf \
powerpc-eabialtivec powerpc-xilinx-eabi powerpc-eabi \
powerpc-rtems \
@@ -96,7 +98,7 @@ LIST = aarch64-elf aarch64-freebsd13 aarch64-linux-gnu aarch64-rtems \
sparc-wrs-vxworks sparc64-elf sparc64-rtems sparc64-linux \
sparc64-netbsd sparc64-openbsd \
v850e1-elf v850e-elf v850-elf v850-rtems vax-linux-gnu \
- vax-netbsdelf visium-elf x86_64-apple-darwin x86_64-gnu \
+ vax-netbsdelf visium-elf x86_64-apple-darwinOPT-with-gnu-as x86_64-gnu \
x86_64-pc-linux-gnuOPT-with-fpmath=avx \
x86_64-elfOPT-with-fpmath=sse x86_64-freebsd13 x86_64-netbsd \
x86_64-w64-mingw32 \